Real Affects of Astrology

Astrology is obviously BS - but being born in summer or winter must make a difference for kids! It's the difference between spending important periods of your life totally bundled up, or running around freely.

There are definitely stages in human development which happen at predictable times - 1 year for first steps, etc, and the variation in the schedule is usually less than a few months - small enough that birth season could matter. So winter babies go through stages together as a group at different times of year from summer babies.

On other Planets?

If we lived on a planet which had longer years, this would be much more pronounced. If a year were 4 Earth years long, a season would last a year. The season you were born in would make a huge difference to you. You'd have more in common with co-seasonals - people 4 years younger or older than you - than with people just the same "age".

You might see winter for the first time at age 2, or age 4! On planets with even longer years, you might spend the first 10 years of your life bundled up, then the next 10 sweating. Those cycles could have reprecussions on the culture as a whole. 80s nights would be categorically different than 70s nights, due to differeing weather in that decade.

Southern Hemisphere

It seems like there should be a way to pretty easily prove or disprove the simple version of astrology: for whatever characteristic that someone claims is related to astrology, look at the data for people in Australia, and see whether the data matches up better as is, or shifted 6 months off.

A Question

  • What is the real birth month distribution of various groups of people?
  • Why isn't this data easier to find? Some months must be much more popular than others.
  • In general does it matter? - If it matters for one group, can you compare another group with a different distribution and make any predictions?
  • For example, two countries with the same population, the same climate, but different holidays may have different birth types. You could use these countries to try to figure out how weather during development makes a difference
  • Are there genes which are optimized for certain types of weather during childhood?

Tags

Related Links

A way Astrology could be RealWhy are Most Chemicals White?Life doesn't Find a WayMonotastersA world with weird selection pressuresPlaying Card Power CyclingTiming OlympicsHow much hair do you grow in a day?Human Physiology and Detective StoriesSelection for Liking Cloning